A version of this story was first published in The Jewish World in October 2015. I am sharing the article for the first time on my blog.
Up until this past May, Larry and I sat in the same seats at Congregation Beth Shalom in Clifton Park. We always sat in the fourth row, left side of the bima, on the two end seats. The Elmans were on the middle aisle, the Grossmans were next to them, and the Toubs sat behind us.
There was a reason for our seating choice. First of all, Larry and I chose to be with close friends. Second of all, Larry liked the end seats so we could get out easily if we needed to take a break. Finally one of two memorial plaque boards were next to us, and we sat right next to the plaques we had gotten in memory of our parents and an uncle. That was our spot every Shabbat service we attended for innumerable years. Sometimes, especially during Rosh Hoshanah and Yom Kippur, we would arrive late and someone else would have taken “our” seats. I am not sure if our angry glare burned a hole in the back of their heads. It would have served them right!
Having one’s spot is ingrained in our brain from our earliest years in school. We were given seats in elementary school, but it was even more formal in the upper grades when we were always seated alphabetically. In home room, I, Marilyn Cohen, sat behind Stephen Bullis from seventh through twelfth grade, the same place we were assigned in many of our classes. Steve wore shirts with a loop in the middle under the seam, and I remember grabbing it and trying to pull it off. I thought my attempt at flirting was cute, but I am sure his parents didn’t like the fact that he was coming home with holes in the back of those nice button downs.
However, even when we are not assigned seats, humans, by habit, tend to choose the same place out of a psychological need. In his book Maximizing Project Success Through Human Performance, industrial psychologist Bernardo Tirado gives this action a name, seat marking. It is a way in which we humans unconsciously mark our territory. ”Think of how many years you sat in assigned seats in school,” says Dr. Tirado. “That level of conditioning continues into our adulthood, even though our seats are no longer assigned.”
Larry and I certainly haven’t outgrown the habit. We eat in our “assigned seats” at our dinner table; we often request the same table and same chairs at a favorite restaurant; we sleep on the same sides of the bed no matter where we are. And when I go to one of my exercise classes, I choose the same spot on the dance floor to follow the instructor. I like to be in the first row in the middle with a clear view of the mirror.
Of course, all this territoriality does cause problems. While taking a Zumba class at the YMCA just before our move, I choose the one empty spot in the first row. A minute before the class was to start, a woman took her place next to me, literally touching my left arm. “Excuse me,” I said. “I am standing here.” “No, this is my spot,” she informed me, and refused to budge.We almost came to blows until I found an empty space in the back of the room.
In our new home, I have also found another spot that is very important in my new life. When weather permits, I move one of the patio chairs in the middle of the open part of the lanai, between the two ferns the former owners left for us. With my feet on the matching hassock and with a cup of Earl Grey tea in my hand, I can look out at “our” pond. It is the best place to observe the bird life and the location of whatever alligator is inhabiting our pond on that particular day. Larry and I have plans of getting a double glider later this winter so that we both can enjoy the view. Not since I was a teenager on Lake Champlain, when I used to sit on the rocks on Willsboro Point overlooking the lake to Burlington have I had a particular place whereI can find such peace and contentment.
Now that we have moved to Florida, I don’t know who sits in our seats at our Clifton Park shul. Has another couple moved into our seats, or are those two blue chairs sitting empty, waiting patiently for us to return? We are too new at Congregation Shalom Aleichem in Kissimmee to have found the place we want to sit on a regular basis. On the first day of Rosh Hoshanah, we found empty seats a few rows back next to a couple we had met, and Wendy saved those seats for us for each of the Yom Kippur services. We’ll have to see if that place continues to work out for us.
After the morning Rosh Hoshanah services, two other couples joined us for a holiday meal. As we moved from the chopped liver and Manischewitz wine in the breakfast nook to the chicken in mushroom sauce, kasha varnishkis, and honeyed carrots at the dining room table, one of my friends asked, “Where would you like us to sit? Do you and Larry have your own special spots?” Larry and I looked at each other questioningly. This was the first time we had ever even eaten in the dining room and had no idea where our spots were. But Larry gravitated to the head of the table, and I chose the seat closest to the kitchen. We all settled into place, said a haMotzi , the traditional prayer over bread, and began our meal. Larry and I had found our spots, and our new new house felt more like our home.

